Showing posts with label constitution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label constitution. Show all posts

Thursday, October 2, 2008

The Violence Against Women Act

With all the talk about Palin's new Couric videos, we're all overlooking something else: what Joe Biden said. I thought Biden's discussion of Roe v. Wade was decent, but I particularly liked his discussion of US v. Morrison, where the Supreme Court struck down the Violence Against Women Act, put forth by Biden himself. His description of the case is a good distillation. Here's the video: (Treat yourself, don't even watch the Palin part.)



The Morrison decision was in 2000, and I thought it might be a good time to talk a little bit about it. The VAWA was written by Biden and aimed at giving women who were the victims of violence a forum to bring a civil suit against their attackers. The case in Morrison was brought by a Virginia Tech freshman who charged two football players with rape. Even though one admitted to having sex after she'd said no, the school did nothing to punish them and a grand jury did not bring charges. This was exactly the kind of case VAWA was created for, when the system at large had failed women.

Morrison struck down The Violence Against Women Act (or VAWA) based on the Commerce Clause. Generally, the powers of the federal government and congress are limited to those enumerated in the Constitution, with the remaining powers left to the states. VAWA relied on the Commerce Clause to gain federal traction, which may sound a little crazy. But Biden had mountains of hours of testimony on the effects of sexual assault on interstate commerce. This was very important. Two previous Supreme Court decisions came into play. One said aggregate effects could be considered to qualify for the Commerce Clause. The second, decided only a few years before Morrison, gave a balancing test with four factors. Two of those four were addressed in VAWA: congressional findings of an economic link, and the strength of the link itself. While the Court recognized that congressional hearings took place, they hardly gave it any weight and instead gave their emphasis to the other factors.

VAWA still exists in a changed form. The federal court remedy is gone, but VAWA still provides funding to fight crime against women. The Morrison case is a staple of Constitutional Law classes all over the country. A lot of people think the Court got it right, that if you can link rape to commerce you can link anything to commerce. Others think that it shows the weaknesses of a Court that uses balancing tests where you weigh different factors. A lot of people thought the test established previously should have made VAWA a close call, but it also gives the ability to pick which ever factors you think are more relevant and ignore others. One notable thing: 36 states filed amicus briefs in support of VAWA. While Morrison struck down VAWA as taking power away from the states, the states themselves acknowledged that they wanted the help.

I know Sarah Palin has got all the women in the world talking. But Biden's sure done his part, and I love that VAWA is still on the top of his mind.

Saturday, September 27, 2008

God Save the Queen

Well I'll be darn...the Brits have finally caught up with the times.
Downing Street has drawn up plans to end the 300-year-old exclusion of Catholics from the throne. The requirement that the succession automatically pass to a male would also be reformed, making it possible for a first born daughter of Prince William to become his heir.
Mind you, I have nothing against Brits, but you've got to admit is has taken an awfully long time for them to get this right. Maybe this explains why the U.S. is so ready to hold on to antiquated notions?

Saturday, January 5, 2008

Child Rape = Death?

I wondered how long it would take for this issue to come before the Supreme Court. Now, come April 2008, the constitutionality of a death penalty sentence for the rape of a child will be heard.

The case revolves around one Patrick Kennedy who was sentenced to death for the rape of his 8-year-old stepdaughter in Louisiana. The death penalty for the crime of rape was deemed unconstitutional by the 1977 Supreme Court finding that, "a sentence of death is grossly disproportionate and excessive punishment for the crime of rape and is therefore forbidden by the Eighth Amendment as cruel and unusual punishment." However, Louisiana legislature passed a law in 1995 allowing the death penalty for the rape of a child under 12 years old. The Louisiana Supreme Court upheld the Kennedy death sentence stating that, "Child rape is the most heinous of all non-homicide crimes...while the majority of other states may not provide capital punishment for child rape, many do provide capital punishment for other non-homicide crimes (that) are far less heinous."

Ah, the protests that will surround this ruling. What a can of worms this opens. As if this the death penalty is not a hot-button issue all on its own. Now toss in another healthy dose of emotion.

I tend to be undecided on the death penalty because its current form is wholly ineffective. Perhaps if death row inmates were not held for decades, one could consider it as a potentially effective means of general deterrence. Since that is not the case, I remain undecided.

However, that is neither here nor there. The issue here, beyond the simple notion of death penalty constitutionality, is the slippery slope of this particular case. What constitutes a child? 16? 12? How old does the perpetrator have to be? What if the rapist is 14? 17? Is it any rape of a child that age or does it have to be especially aggravated? Even so, is that worthy of death? Going back to
Coker v. Georgia 1977 Supreme Court ruling, “we have the abiding conviction that the death penalty, which is unique in its severity and irrevocability, is an excessive penalty for the rapist who, as such, does not take human life.”

Perhaps this post should have been placed at our less feminist blog, The Journal of Modern Armchair Philosophies, however, there is the undeniable feminist undertone to this case since the crime of rape in and of itself is often not taken as seriously as it should be.